My background: I have been flying for 11 years and teaching for 8, in a variety of aircraft, most of them taildraggers. My experience is in 50 different types, with type ratings in the L-39 Albatros and TBM Avenger. I consider my niche to be the teaching of "stick and rudder" flying that focuses on the details of precise and confident aircraft handling, in a wide envelope of situations (tailwheel flying, aerobatics, unusual attitudes, etc.).
Scope and purpose: The target audience is pilots of every experience level, from students (even enthusiasts that haven't flown) to current instructors, to seasoned veterans. Hasn't aerodynamics been covered enough over the last century? Why reinvent the wheel? What new knowledge can I contribute to "how to fly an airplane?"
There isn't any new material I can contribute, but I hope to carefully dissect and explain current issues of practical aerodynamics in a way that fosters a deeper understanding of how they affect the airplane's behavior, and connect this academic knowledge to the control inputs we make daily in the cockpit. This is a connection that, unfortunately, I see missing too much of the time. If it was present, then experienced pilots wouldn't fail to answer basic questions I ask them like "what makes an airplane turn?" or "why does airspeed fall off in a climb?" A lack of understanding on this level should leave one stunned, but nonetheless, those same pilots could fly a fine turn and climb just half an hour before.
Instead of this scripted set of control inputs, the mindset I try to inculcate into my students is to understand what they want the airplane to do, how to accomplish that task with the controls they have, and why those control inputs have that effect. An understanding of this third element is the key that can make the other two happen successfully and reliably in every case, not just those that the "scripts" are written around.
I think that this scripted mindset is a result of modern flight training materials that gloss over aerodynamics in an overly cursory way, and really pay the topic lip service only to the extent that a student can pass a written test instead of meaningfully teaching the concepts. (For without an understanding of how or why the airplane does what it does, what else is a pilot to do but follow the scripts?)
The name of the blog is inspired by, and pays homage to, Wolfgang Langewiche's famous book Stick and Rudder. One of its negative reviews on Amazon accuses it of being boring and repetitive, and says "Thank God they don't write books today like they used to." I have the opposite sentiment. In front of me is the Jeppesen Private Pilot Manual, and a mere 66 of its ~800 pages contain the section "Principles of Aerodynamics," of which more than half is graphics and the rest very condensed quick blurbs. It seems almost like an afterthought, crammed among other necessary topics like navigation, airport operations, physiology, etc. I, of course, understand the necessity to cover all the other material, but as a result, all of the aerodynamics has been relegated to an afterthought, without connection from the topics themselves to how they affect us in the air.
The good thing about old books is that they're still around, and you can order a copy of Stick and Rudder in 2 minutes. Like other training media of its era, it slowly and carefully goes through the material, and uses repetition (as well as correlation to real-life) to drive the point home where it might be missed from a single pass. My goal with this blog is to bridge the gap between Stick and Rudder, and my other favorite flying book, Aerodynamics for Naval Aviators, another perennial classic that approaches the problem from a very different perspective. Using a lot of math and charts, (which many describe as the language of physics) it describes exactly what happens and why, where Wolfgang Langewiesche skillfully navigates the topics with mostly words alone, in an almost poetic, and much easier for a layman to understand, way. My goal, in a wider sense, is to help the people truly understand flying at a fundamental level.
While this blog probably won't reinvent the wheel, it really is a way for me to organize my own thoughts, both for myself and my students, in a way that I can point them to and give them comprehensive coverage on a particular topic that might arise from a more focused discussion in a debrief. Any other readers on the internet will hopefully find the posts valuable. Some of them will be straightforward explanations of situations in flying, that can be used either as lesson material or elucidation in someone's understanding of some maneuver, while others will offer perspectives in some topics that tend to lead to heated debates.
So I welcome any and all readers to participate in my passion for teaching How to Fly an Airplane, instead of things like the difference between a FDC NOTAM and a NOTAM-D, or the chart markings for the different floors of Class E. We'll see if I can gather up any sort of regular readership, (I've always wondered how other people do it from ground zero). I absolutely encourage comments, and hope that lively discussions develop in the comment sections (in additions to simple questions, calls for clarification, or anything else.)
The name of the blog is inspired by, and pays homage to, Wolfgang Langewiche's famous book Stick and Rudder. One of its negative reviews on Amazon accuses it of being boring and repetitive, and says "Thank God they don't write books today like they used to." I have the opposite sentiment. In front of me is the Jeppesen Private Pilot Manual, and a mere 66 of its ~800 pages contain the section "Principles of Aerodynamics," of which more than half is graphics and the rest very condensed quick blurbs. It seems almost like an afterthought, crammed among other necessary topics like navigation, airport operations, physiology, etc. I, of course, understand the necessity to cover all the other material, but as a result, all of the aerodynamics has been relegated to an afterthought, without connection from the topics themselves to how they affect us in the air.
The good thing about old books is that they're still around, and you can order a copy of Stick and Rudder in 2 minutes. Like other training media of its era, it slowly and carefully goes through the material, and uses repetition (as well as correlation to real-life) to drive the point home where it might be missed from a single pass. My goal with this blog is to bridge the gap between Stick and Rudder, and my other favorite flying book, Aerodynamics for Naval Aviators, another perennial classic that approaches the problem from a very different perspective. Using a lot of math and charts, (which many describe as the language of physics) it describes exactly what happens and why, where Wolfgang Langewiesche skillfully navigates the topics with mostly words alone, in an almost poetic, and much easier for a layman to understand, way. My goal, in a wider sense, is to help the people truly understand flying at a fundamental level.
While this blog probably won't reinvent the wheel, it really is a way for me to organize my own thoughts, both for myself and my students, in a way that I can point them to and give them comprehensive coverage on a particular topic that might arise from a more focused discussion in a debrief. Any other readers on the internet will hopefully find the posts valuable. Some of them will be straightforward explanations of situations in flying, that can be used either as lesson material or elucidation in someone's understanding of some maneuver, while others will offer perspectives in some topics that tend to lead to heated debates.
So I welcome any and all readers to participate in my passion for teaching How to Fly an Airplane, instead of things like the difference between a FDC NOTAM and a NOTAM-D, or the chart markings for the different floors of Class E. We'll see if I can gather up any sort of regular readership, (I've always wondered how other people do it from ground zero). I absolutely encourage comments, and hope that lively discussions develop in the comment sections (in additions to simple questions, calls for clarification, or anything else.)
This is a great idea!
ReplyDeleteI remember my first flight with you when I was going after my tail wheel endorsement. You told me to look straight forward and remember the 3 point attitude. That worked out well for me since I went on to buy a Super D. I have since sold that airplane and now own a 1952 Cessna 195. The first time I sat it that airplane it didn't feel right. I tried to look straight forward to learn the 3 point attitude and eventually realized that I was no longer sitting in the middle of the airplane. This is a very awkward view. Not because I have never flown a side by side, but because nothing about my view is symmetrical to anything. I haven't learned what visual cues I can use to tell if I'm aligned with the runway on approach and touch down and because my butt is very close to being right on top of the main landing gear I can't "feel" when the airplane wants to yaw.
I should probably let you know that I am still not checked out in the airplane and the two pilots that I have arranged to check me out are constantly telling me that this airplane will put me in the ditch at the first sign of inattention.
The two things that get pilots that fly 195s in trouble is the left turning tendencies on take off with strong left quartering headwinds (little rudder) and not flying the aircraft on the roll out until it is at taxi speed.
The decathlon was pretty forgiving when I got a little "ham fisted" with the throttle or was a little sloppy with my yaw control on approach and landing. The 195 is NOT.
I think a better understanding of left turning tendencies would help new students develop better rudder and power control during take off and landing. That was one thing I lacked, before I learned to fly copters of course, when I was learning to fly. It's not that I didn't understand the forces involved. It was just never really demonstrated in enough detail for me to understand why they are so important, and if not understood , how they can put you on a path to ground loops and unexpected runway departures.
Hi, thanks for the support!
ReplyDeleteIt's definitely harder to tell if you're aligned in a side-by-side airplane. There are 2 "angles" (har har) that I approach that problem with. First, I actually disregard the nose of the airplane (which seems to go against everything I've ever said about flying an airplane... but disregard it in yaw only; very much continue regarding it in pitch!) and think about my own body. You know those Renaissance painters who studied human bodies and drew lines and angles and all sorts of geometrical stuff through them? Well do that to yourself. More specifically, imagine a nice, straight line passing through your shoulders perfectly side-to-side, and another line passing forward and back through the center your chest, perfectly at right angles through the other one. Imagine that line passing continuing out to infinity, straight as a laser... that defines your body's longitudinal axis, and you want to make that parallel to the centerline.
The next thing might or might not conflict with what your instructor is telling you, and if it does, listen to him! But otherwise... try to land not so that the airplane's centerline is on the runway centerline, but so that your body's centerline is on the runway centerline. That'll make it much easier to line up; you just have to get good at imagining that body axis! Nice, square shoulders! To further help with this, tow or push the airplane to somewhere with a long straight line on the ramp, so that it's 1) positioned under the middle of the left seat, and 2) perfectly parallel. Now you can have a seat and look forward, and comfortably learn what it should look like. Maybe even put some tape marks on the cowl and dash (both near and far) to act as line markers.
And left turning tendencies are perfect fodder for future posts!